Bribery: Fine Imposed Instead of Imprisonment

High Court allows appeal

 

1. Introduction

Suang Wijaya and Haziq Ika bin Zahidi acted for an offender who pleaded guilty to three charges of bribery under Section 6(b) of the Prevention of Corruption Act Singapore (“PCA”), with two remaining PCA charges taken into consideration for purposes of sentencing.

The total amount of gratification involved was less than SGD 30,000. The Prosecution did not argue that any party had suffered detriment or loss.

Before the District Judge, we vigorously argued that a fine was just and fair. However, the District Judge disagreed with our submission. The District Judge sentenced the offender to three-months’ imprisonment.

Dissatisfied, our client appealed against the sentence imposed by the District Judge.

We had conduct of the appeal. We submitted among other things that, based on the evidence before her, the District Judge was clearly wrong to find that:- (a) our client had “initiated” the bribes; (b) there was “substantial benefit” which had accrued to our client; and (c) there was a “significant degree of persistent offending”.

 

2. The Appeal

The appeal came up for hearing before a High Court Judge on 4 October 2019. At the conclusion of the hearing, the Judge allowed the appeal. The Judge agreed with us that it was manifest that an imprisonment sentence was not justified. The Judge quashed the imprisonment sentence. A fine was imposed instead.

 

3. Conclusion

We are pleased with the result of this case. As we previously mentioned in Amicable Resolution of Criminal Case, as criminal lawyers we take seriously our professional duty to pursue every reasonable defence and raise every favourable factor in accordance with the law. This duty applies equally to persons convicted of crime, even serious crime.

oangledes213

Recent Posts

Beautician acquitted of allegations that she had performed injections in contravention of the Medical Registration Act

Following four days of trial in the District Court, the learned District Judge Eddy Tham…

1 year ago

High Court reduces sentence of knife-wielding man shot in Clementi

Eugene Thuraisingam LLP successfully reduced the jail sentence of Mr Soo Cheow Wee, who was…

1 year ago

Contract: High Court dismisses claim for breach of contract

Eugene Thuraisingam LLP successful in defending company and its director against claims brought by a…

2 years ago

Roszaidi bin Osman v PP – Court of Appeal Reduces Drug Courier’s Death Penalty to Life Sentence

This article outlines how the death penalty in a drug trafficking case was reduced to…

2 years ago

PP v Miya Manik – Court of Appeal upholds acquittal of man charged with murder

The High Court's acquittal of a man who was charged with Murder has been upheld…

2 years ago

Chelsea Tan Yan Qi v PP – Sentencing Principles on imposing fines for Indigent Offenders

In this case, the High Court clarified sentencing principles on imposing fines on indigent offenders.

2 years ago