High Court reduces sentence of knife-wielding man shot in Clementi
The jail sentence of Mr Soo Cheow Wee (“Mr Soo”), was on 31 July 2023 reduced on appeal from an aggregate sentence of 33 months’ imprisonment to 27 months’ imprisonment, in an appeal heard by the Honourable Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon (“CJ Menon”) sitting in the General Division of the High Court of Singapore.
In September 2022, Mr Soo pleaded guilty to four proceeded charges including criminal intimidation and voluntarily causing hurt with a dangerous weapon. Three charges pertained to an incident in February 2022 where he was eventually shot outside Clementi Police Division, while one charge pertained to a separate incident in 2019.
Before the District Court, the Prosecution sought a sentence of at least five years, and in the alternative, an aggregate imprisonment term of 57 to 63 months’ imprisonment. The learned District Judge Luke Tan sentenced Mr Soo to 33 months imprisonment.
Both the Prosecution and Defence filed appeals against the sentence.
On appeal, the Prosecution repeated its contention that at least five years’ Corrective Training (CT) be imposed, or in the alternative, 57 to 63 months’ imprisonment.
The Defence contended that an aggregate sentence of not more than 23 months’ imprisonment would be appropriate.
On 31 July 2023, the Honourable CJ Menon issued his judgment in PP v Soo Cheow Wee [2023] SGHC 204, dismissing the Prosecution’s appeal and allowing the Defence’s cross-appeal in part. This judgment provides important clarifications on the principles governing the consideration of mental conditions in sentencing as well as the sentencing framework for offences of voluntarily causing hurt with a dangerous weapon.
The Court found that Mr Soo’s pre-existing mental conditions, including schizophrenia and substance induced psychosis, substantially impaired his responsibility for his actions and the offences, including his impulse control and decision-making abilities at the time of the offences, thus reducing his culpability.
Mr Soo was represented by our Chooi Jing Yen and Ng Yuan Siang, with the support of the Criminal Legal Aid Scheme (CLAS). The Prosecution was led by Deputy Attorney-General Tai Wei Shyong, Senior Counsel and DPP R Arvindren.
The full grounds of decision are available by clicking the “Read More” link below.
Recent Criminal Cases
September 7, 2023
Following four days of trial in the District Court, the learned District Judge Eddy Tham acquitted a beautician of a charge that she had injected dermal fillers into the face of a Vietnamese woman in contravention Section 13(a) of the Medical Registration Act (the “MRA“) and punishable under Section 17(1)(e) of the MRA. The judge […]
Roszaidi bin Osman v PP – Court of Appeal Reduces Drug Courier’s Death Penalty to Life Sentence
December 15, 2022
This article outlines how the death penalty in a drug trafficking case was reduced to a life sentence on the ground of diminished responsibility.
PP v Miya Manik – Court of Appeal upholds acquittal of man charged with murder
November 15, 2022
The High Court's acquittal of a man who was charged with Murder has been upheld by Singapore's Court of Appeal in PP v Miya Manik
Chelsea Tan Yan Qi v PP – Sentencing Principles on imposing fines for Indigent Offenders
November 3, 2022
In this case, the High Court clarified sentencing principles on imposing fines on indigent offenders.
Section 377A appeals dismissed by the Court of Appeal
February 27, 2022
Section 377A appeals were dismissed by the Court of Appeal. We remain hopeful for full decriminalisation of homosexual sex in Singapore in the future.
